The 12 Cs of Trust vs The Five Behaviors: Which Team Trust Assessment Fits Your Team?
Both approaches put trust at the base of team performance. They differ in what they measure, how finely, and what happens after the assessment. Here is a side-by-side comparison, written by the firm behind one of them, so read it with that in mind.
What is the difference between the 12 Cs of Trust and The Five Behaviors?
The Five Behaviors is Wiley’s facilitated team program built on Patrick Lencioni’s model, scoring five broad behaviors with Everything DiSC® styles. The 12 Cs of Trust is DreamSmart’s framework that scores trust itself as twelve observable behaviors, then works the lowest one in coaching sprints on live business problems and re-measures.
In short: The Five Behaviors measures how a team performs across the whole Lencioni pyramid, with trust as one of five scales. The 12 Cs zoom in on the base of that pyramid and split trust into the specific behaviors that build or break it.
Side by side
| The Five Behaviors | 12 Cs of Trust (TrustFlow™) | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Patrick Lencioni's The Five Dysfunctions of a Team (2002), developed into a program by Wiley | Jeff Morris, DreamSmart Behavioral Solutions; documented in the TrustFlow™ whitepapers |
| What is scored | Trust, conflict, commitment, accountability and results, plus each person's DiSC® style | Twelve trust behaviors in four quadrants: Foundations, Essentials, Work and Results |
| How trust is defined | Vulnerability-based trust: willingness to admit mistakes and weaknesses | Twelve observable behaviors, from Character and Courage to Clarify and Closeout |
| Scale | Team scores on five scales; individual style report | Each C rated 1 to 5; combined into the TrustFlow Index |
| Delivery | Assessment, then a one-day or three-day facilitated session led by a trained facilitator | Baseline, then coaching sprints on live issues, then re-measurement |
| Best at | Giving a whole team a shared model and language for cohesion | Pinpointing which trust behavior broke down and tracking whether it improves |
Program details for The Five Behaviors are summarized from Wiley’s published materials at fivebehaviors.com.
When The Five Behaviors is the better fit
- The team has never worked with a shared teamwork model and needs a common language first.
- The organization already uses Everything DiSC® and wants the team profile to connect to it.
- You want a self-contained program run by an internal or external certified facilitator.
- The main issue is clearly higher up the pyramid, such as commitment to decisions or focus on collective results.
When the 12 Cs of Trust is the better fit
- The team agrees trust is the problem but cannot say which part of it, so it needs a finer diagnosis than one trust scale.
- The trust breakdown is about reliability, ownership or follow-through, not only vulnerability. Clarify, Commitment, Consistency and Closeout cover those directly.
- A previous workshop worked for a few weeks and then faded, and the team needs practice on live work with re-measurement.
- Leaders want a number they can track over time, the TrustFlow Index, alongside business outcomes.
Using both together
The two are not mutually exclusive, and DreamSmart has worked from Five Behaviors results. In the California North case study, a regional leadership team at a Fortune 500 homebuilder started from an initial Five Behaviors assessment, which showed trust, conflict and commitment in the mid-range and accountability in the low range. Rather than another workshop, the team ran six TrustFlow™ coaching sprints on live issues across land, construction and sales.
That is a natural division of labor. The Five Behaviors shows where on the pyramid a team is struggling. The 12 Cs show which specific behaviors to change, and TrustFlow™ sprints turn that into weekly practice. For a fair summary of the underlying model, see the Five Dysfunctions of a Team, explained.
How the scales map onto each other
This mapping is DreamSmart’s interpretation, offered to help teams that have results from one approach and want to read them against the other.
| Five Behaviors scale | Closest 12 Cs behaviors |
|---|---|
| Trust | Character, Connection, Caring, Communication |
| Conflict | Courage, Collaboration |
| Commitment | Clarify, Commitment |
| Accountability | Commitment, Coaching, Consistency |
| Results | Competence, Closeout |
The full definitions of each C, with what it looks like present and absent, are in the 12 Cs of Trust.
The Five Behaviors® and Everything DiSC® are trademarks of John Wiley & Sons, Inc. The Five Dysfunctions of a Team is a book by Patrick Lencioni. DreamSmart Behavioral Solutions is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, the owners of the other framework. Descriptions of it are summaries based on its publicly available materials; TrustFlow™ and the 12 Cs of Trust are DreamSmart’s.
Frequently asked questions
What is The Five Behaviors assessment?
It is an assessment-based team program from Wiley built on Patrick Lencioni's Five Dysfunctions model. Team members complete an online assessment that scores the team on trust, conflict, commitment, accountability and results and identifies each person's DiSC style, followed by a facilitated session.
Is the 12 Cs of Trust an alternative to The Five Behaviors?
It can be used instead or alongside. The 12 Cs focus on trust in finer detail, as twelve observable behaviors, and pair the assessment with coaching sprints and re-measurement. Teams with Five Behaviors results can use them as a starting point.
Which is better for a leadership team?
It depends on the problem. For a shared teamwork language, The Five Behaviors is well established. For a precise diagnosis of which trust behaviors are breaking down and a way to track change over months, the 12 Cs and the TrustFlow Index are built for that.
Can I take a 12 Cs assessment for free?
Yes. The DreamSmart Trust Score is a free twelve-question check, about three minutes, that rates a team on the 12 Cs and returns the behavior to work on first. A full leadership-team diagnostic is a paid engagement.